Desserts in Franklin Square

Italian-inspired desserts at Olive and Garlic in Franklin Square, NY include cakes, doughnuts and gelato, available for pickup.

Order online

Desserts to Try

Tiramisu

$7.99

Espresso-soaked ladyfingers layered with mascarpone and cocoa.

“Cute tiny spot with great food. Everything was delicious. We had La Italia Pizza, Chicken Parm ala Vodka, Eggplant, Calamari, and tiramisu for dessert. Service was friendly and gave us banana pudding on the house to try their new addition to the dessert menu. Planning to come back real soon!”

Fried Zeppole With Nutella

$12.99

Warm fried doughnuts are dusted with sugar and served with Nutella.

“The food is amazing!! I love the honey hot pizza and you can taste they use high quality ingredients!! Today was our first time ordering the Nutella zeppoles and it was slight crispy and super soft inside! My kids devoured it!”

Molten Lava Cake

$9.99

Warm chocolate cake with a molten dark chocolate center.

“Great food and service. Get the chocolate cake and eggplant parm”

Gelato

$9.99

Italian gelato is dense and creamy, with flavors varying by day.

Nutella Pizza

$13.99

Wood-fired dough topped with warm Nutella and powdered sugar.

Ricotta & Pistachio Cake

$6.99

Ricotta cake with toasted pistachio and a delicate, nutty finish.

At the Heart of Olive and Garlic

Olive and Garlic serves desserts from Sicilian-inspired cake with creamy ricotta and toasted pistachio to Italian-style dessert pizza, with golden wood-fired dough, warm Nutella and powdered sugar.

Fried Zeppole With Nutella comes warm and fried to order; Molten Lava Cake has a molten dark chocolate center, while Tiramisu combines espresso-soaked ladyfingers and sweet mascarpone cream.

Visit Olive and Garlic in Franklin Square, NY for pickup or dine-in. Finish with Gelato, made in the traditional Italian style with a texture that is distinctly denser and creamier than ice cream.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular desserts options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

Nutella Pizza — Wood-fired pizza dough is baked golden, spread with warm Nutella, then finished with a dusting of powdered sugar.
Fried Zeppole With Nutella — These warm Italian doughnuts are fried to order, dusted with powdered sugar, and served with Nutella for dipping.
Tiramisu — This Italian dessert layers espresso-soaked ladyfingers with sweet mascarpone cream and finishes with a dusting of cocoa; it is made in house.
Ricotta & Pistachio Cake — This Sicilian-inspired cake combines creamy ricotta with toasted pistachio for a delicate texture and nutty flavor without excessive sweetness.